I have a hard time not reading a book in its entirety. Once I start, I feel like I’ve failed if I don’t read to the end. Or maybe the book has failed me?
I suppose this is why, after four failed attempts at getting beyond the fifty-page mark of Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard, I gritted my teeth and persevered. After all, I had been given the three books in the series so far, as well as the companion book, Cruel Crown, which includes two short back stories from the point of view of supporting characters.
Am I happy I persevered enough to read all four?
No. And, yes.
Let me explain.
This series consists of a hierarchical dystopian society complete with a girl who finds out she has a special power, a potential love triangle (or quadrangle, depending on how you look at it), and a growing rebellion. Those with extraordinary powers (the Silvers) wield these powers to maintain control over those without (the Reds). Trouble is, the main character, a Red girl named Mare, develops a special power of her own. The Silvers are not pleased, to say the least, and try to pass Mare off as a long-lost Silver (yeah, right) until they can figure out what to do with her. With no choice but to live this new life, Mare tries from within royal circles to help the Red rebellion.
I don’t want to say much more about the actual story – I hate posts brimming with spoiler alerts – so instead…
First of all, I found Mare a little annoying, probably due to the fact that much of her dialogue was followed up with internal monologue and/or explanation (loads of Tell over Show here, guys). I was seldom allowed, as the reader, to come up with my own interpretation on how she was feeling and what she was thinking. I also found many of the characters quite stereotypical – evil queen, loyal best friend, wise older teacher, mean girl gang, and traditional older prince. A bit ho-hum.
The plot twists as a whole came across rather weak and poorly conceived. For instance, on her first day on the job and with no training, Mare was put to work at the most important event on the calendar. Really? Was this the best way to introduce her special skill? And the main villain was too easy to identify. If someone’s too good to be true, they usually are, right? Too cliché.
But my biggest peeve was the use of point of view. Take the first book, Red Queen, written in Mare’s first-person point of view. This girl sure has an amazing way of hopping into another’s head. Another special power, perhaps? For example:
“Maven is more desperate, surprising himself as much as me. He knows I’m sinking fast, a stone dropped through the river. And he wants to drown with me.”
This continues in Glass Sword, the second book:
“Grateful for the change in conversation, he pulls himself together.”
And King’s Cage, the third book:
“He walks forward, fighting the deep instinct to fear this place.”
How does Mare know what these characters are feeling??? In each of these examples, there is no indication through their actions or words that would lead her to these conclusions. She may suspect, especially in the later books once she knows these characters better, but they are all still assumptions on her part. Is she some sort of all-knowing deity?
So why did I continue? Why did I read them all? Because once I finished the first book, there was no going back. For all of its simplicity, and as long as I could take note of flaws and move on, I came to enjoy the story Victoria Aveyard had created and the world it inhabited. I grew fond of the characters, under-developed though they may be, especially some of those supporting. Going forward, the stories surrounding characters such as Evangeline and Cameron actually interest me more than Mare’s. Something to do with their internal conflict, I suspect.
So if you want standard run-of-the-mill escapism, and don’t dissect the plot/characters/style too much, this series could be for you. But if you’re looking for something totally unexpected and fresh, with writing that leaves you breathless, hmmm, maybe not so much.
Will I buy the next book? Maybe…yes, unless I’m given that one as well 🙂
I’ve come too far.
Until next time,
Happy writing (and reading),